Superstore
AUCTIONS
Getty Images
Juan Montoya and Kasey Kahne have each shown tremendous improvement over last season.

Head2Head: Who can race their way into the Chase?

By NASCAR.COM
May 27, 2009
12:45 PM EDT
Save Article Email Article Print Article RSS
type size: + -

As the Cup Series approaches the halfway mark before the Chase for the Sprint Cup begins, four drivers are within 100 points of 12th-place Mark Martin -- David Reutimann, Juan Montoya, Kasey Kahne and Brian Vickers.

While most agree the current top 12 is pretty stout, one driver could stumble opening the door for one of those four to take his place, the question is ... who?

Jason Schoellen goes with experience in his pick while Bill Kimm thinks someone will make his Chase debut. Read both sides and then weigh in with your takeexternal link. And don't forget to vote on whose argument you agree with the most.

Which driver can race their way into the Chase?

KASEY KAHNE JUAN MONTOYA

When picking who will make the Chase, there are four reasons Kasey Kahne gets the nod on Juan Montoya.

The success. Kahne has wins at four of the tracks remaining before the Chase cutoff. He won at Pocono last spring and also has victories at Atlanta, Michigan and Richmond. Montoya, meanwhile, has only won at Infineon in a fuel-mileage finish. Looking at last year's Dover-to-Richmond run (accounting for the Fontana/Atlanta swap), Kahne posted a better average finish than Montoya: 19.92 to 27.35.

The experience. Kahne has felt the pressure of the Chase, while Montoya hasn't. In addition to making the field in 2006, Kahne was in contention in 2004 and 2008 as he finished 13th and 14th in the points, respectively.

The engine. The only thing slowing Kahne down this year (literally) has been a lack of horsepower. Starting this weekend, he will have the new Dodge R6P8 engine under his hood which should provide improved giddy-up. The power plant has done wonders for Penske drivers this season and will help Kahne in his push to make the Chase.

The momentum. In the last 10 races, Kahne has accumulated more points than Montoya and was reeling in race leader Kyle Busch before the final rain delay in the Coca-Cola 600.

Brash open-wheel veteran or soft-spoken young Sprint Cup star battling for a Chase berth -- this round goes to Kahne.

Jason Schoellen, NASCAR.COM

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

This is the year Juan Montoya gets over the hump and makes the Chase -- and team morale and attitude are a big reason for the boost.

With Earnhardt-Ganassi Racing, Montoya has found some stability. Brain Pattie is the perfect crew chief for Montoya and their stellar working relationship is starting to show in the results column. The goal for the team is to finish at least in the top 15, and it seems to be working.

The improvements in Year 3 of his Cup career are impressive. He hasn't won a race yet, but his four top-10s are two off his career best of six back in 2007. On top of that, his average start is seven spots better than his career average (14.8/21.4) and his average finish is six spots on the positive (16.1/22.4).

Only once this season has Montoya finished worse than 30th. In the last eight events, the No. 42 has put up a top-20 in seven of them, including his four top-10s.

But most impressive in Montoya's 2009 season -- no DNFs. In '07 he finished with four and last year it jumped to nine. This year, though, he has nine lead lap finishes and has stayed out of trouble.

Montoya is seeing these tracks for a fourth, fifth and sixth time. He's more comfortable in the car now than at any other point in his Cup career and it shows with his finishes. He's still learning, but he's also good enough to make the top 12.

Bill Kimm, NASCAR.COM

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

The End

Share Article Save Article Email Article Print Article RSS
  • MySpace
  • Facebook
  • Digg
 

Also

POPULAR ALERTS
or Create Your Own

Poll

Whose argument do you agree with the most?
Jason Schoellen
Bill Kimm
Neither
view results

Sprint Cup Series

Driver Standings
Pos. +/- Driver Points Behind
1. -- Jeff Gordon 1722 Leader
2. -- Tony Stewart 1678 -44
3. -- Kurt Busch 1607 -115
4. -- Jimmie Johnson 1594 -128
5. -- Denny Hamlin 1575 -147
6. +1 Kyle Busch 1540 -182
7. +1 Ryan Newman 1538 -184
8. -2 Jeff Burton 1472 -250
9. +1 Matt Kenseth 1460 -262
10. -1 Greg Biffle 1448 -274
11. +1 Carl Edwards 1431 -291
12. -1 Mark Martin 1428 -294
13. +2 David Reutimann 1422 -300
14. -- Juan Montoya 1397 -325
15. +1 Kasey Kahne 1351 -371
16. +1 Brian Vickers 1348 -374

Remember To Check Out

All External sites will open in a new browser window. NASCAR.COM does not endorse external sites.
© 2001-2009 NASCAR | Turner Sports Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Turner Entertainment Digital Network NASCAR.COM is part of the Turner Sports and Entertainment Digital Network.